|
Buddhism & Yoga
(The earliest version
With the Buddhistic doctrine the
Yoga was connected from
the beginning, because it was the
way by which The Buddha,
the founder of Buddhism, had found
Deliverance
Prof. Erich Frauwallner
|
|
|
|
Religion of the Heart Throughout Saint Guru Chod's more than forty-year teaching career, he initiated thousands in the Timeless Yoga. He furthermore imbued his precious teaching with a cogent appraisal of the ancient Buddha-Dharma, the religious culture in which he was born. For the Guru was by no means a divisive rebel. Moreover, it is very much incumbent on any individual who has managed that leap beyond the quagmire of nescience to stand as a glowing illustration of the fact that the whole of humankind belongs to one great religion, the religion of the heart. "In actual fact," the Master explained, " a yogi, or yoginī, is just one type of religious ascetic who is searching for an end to suffering. Speaking metaphorically, the goal of all religions is to reach the summit of a glorious mountain. Yoga is just one path among many. Though yoga is not a religion in-itself, it has always been adopted, adapted, and applied by all religions.[1] Broadly speaking, the Vedic term yoga pertains to any form of asceticism or meditative technique, including prayer[2]. Though methods and philosophies differ greatly, the various paths approach the same goal. To embrace all religions is to fully comprehend that you are not alone in your need to surmount human suffering, such nostalgia being, in effect, universal.
|
|
Enter the Rishi
In Yoga, one of Saint Guru Chod's three published books in Thai, he explains why people generally – and Thais especially – hold many vague and incorrect ideas about yoga. He makes it clear why people in Thailand think that a yogi is the same as a hermit. This is because in the Thai language a hermit is called a ruesi, (Khmer, rosei) from Sanskrit rishī, that is, "a forest dwelling visionary." Writes the Guru, Due to customary Thai folklore, people commonly picture yogis as bearded, unkempt and unclean ascetics, living naked and alone in the forest depths while subsisting on gathered herbs and vegetables. Through piercing concentration and arcane sorcery, they imagine that yogis can lie on beds of nails, be buried alive and withstand extreme temperatures while standing on their heads. They believe that yogis can perform marvellous feats, such as flying about on magic carpets, or creating goddesses out of thin air and making them their spiritual consorts! But don't be misled," the Master warns, A practitioner of yoga is by no means required to retire from the secular world, sever all relations with human society and dwell in the seclusion of a comfortless cave. He can go on leading a fully active mundane existence, and when he walks down the road he can be quite sure that nobody would take a second look at him, or find in him anything peculiar. In particular regard to the rishi, however, it is worthy of note that in the oldest surviving Buddhist texts, it is the Buddha himself who is referred to as the "rishī," though in its Pāli form īsi[3].
|
|
Maharishi Buddhadasa
While undergoing training at
Wat Suan Mokh, the famous forest hermitage of Maharishi
Buddhadasa Bhikkhu,[4]
the present writer was exceptionally honoured to have gained
private meetings with the age stricken patriarch of modern
|
|
The Royal Eight-Fold Path of Yoga
Throughout Saint Guru Chod's long and illustrious career, he stove to reveal the great similarities between the two remotely ancient systems of Buddhism and Yoga. In fact, both saints Guru Chod and Buddhadasa Bhikkhu openly spoke and wrote on what they intimately knew as Raja-yoga. Raja-yoga represents the oldest known school of Classical Indian Yoga. It dates back more than two thousand years. In the Sanskrit language, raja means, "king." This Kingly Yoga was first given shape by the time-honoured Indian sage Maharishi Patañjali in his classic treatise Yoga Sūtras (Yoga Aphorisms). It is also known as ashtānga-yoga. In Sanskrit, ashta means "eight," anga means "part." This is why Patañjali's raja-yoga is also referred to as The Royal Eight-Fold Path of Yoga.
|
|
Buddha as a Yogi The great similarities between Buddhism and Yoga have led many scholars to accept their common pre-historical source. We know for a certainty that as a fledgling ascetic, Gautama thoroughly steeped himself in the pre-classic Indian philosophy of his revered teacher Arāda Kālāma "living midst the forests and cave rich hills of the Vindhya Mountains" near Vaishālī. It was his second guru, the "Thera" Udraka Rāmaputra, who taught the Bodhisattva the principles of yoga. As early as the year 1900, the esteemed French savant Emile Senart arrived to a singularly momentous conclusion,
It was on the terrain of Yoga
that the Buddha arose; whatever innovations he was able to
introduce into it, the mould of Yoga was that in which his
thought was formed Other writers have expressed the same idea. "How could Buddha, possessor of an intelligence without peer, spend six years of his life fruitlessly?" Japanese writer Kanjitsu Iijima rhetorically asks; and goes on to plead, "It is an undeniable historical fact that Yoga played a part in the origin of Buddhism"[6]. Sri Lankan professor Ananda Guruge concurs: "Though the self-mortification implied in [early Indian asceticism] was not approved by the Buddha, the yogic element...formed a basic feature in the course of training by the Buddha[7]. Now, Austrian Professor Erich Frauwallner is by far the most incisive in declaring Yoga's role in the formation of early Buddhism. In his two-volume History of Indian Philosophy, Frauwallner writes, With the Buddhistic doctrine the Yoga was connected from the beginning, because it was the way by which The Buddha, the founder of Buddhism, had found Deliverance.[8] The Buddha spent six years undergoing yogic training. But after he reached the highest plane, he still felt the urge to go beyond. Conventionally, yogis have approached the goal of emancipation by two principal paths. One is the path of metaphysical knowledge; the other is the path of ascetic practice. The first of these approaches is often called viveka, or "the razor's edge path of sage discrimination." The second approach is usually distinguished by its penchant for exploring the myriad states of human consciousness through yogic practices. Now, as for yoga and the majority of the Buddhist schools, greater underscoring is normally given to the ascetic path of yoga practice.
Gautama
|
Buddha As Hindu
Honouring his commitment to
the chaste student life (brahmācharya-āsrama)
|
The Forbidden Buddha One cannot be blind to the obvious fact the Buddhist religion was born in India, that epochal land of world renunciation where philosophers, ascetics and a vast array of religious visionaries have long set their sights on a pristine spontaneity called nirvāna. Nor can one forget that in its primacy, the Buddha's Doctrine was not conceived as a new religion. What is widely regarded today as "Buddhism," should actually be viewed as the natural outgrowth of a great cenobitical heritage dating back roughly 3,000 years. It is also apparent that the Buddha himself foresaw and feared the eventual error of his yogic movement transforming itself into a full-blown religious cult. Attempting to forestall this inevitable distortion, Gautama strongly forbade his followers to fashion images of his human form. We know from history that for many generations following the Buddha's physical demise, a tremendous reverence was maintained among his devotees to observe this important prohibition. Yet slowly and steadily as adherents grew, they began to commemorate him – not directly, but implicitly, first through memorial stupas, later by cut stone bas-reliefs of the figurative Bo tree. At Sañchi, for example, to handle the Buddha's ineffable being, carved expanses of sea and sky were suggested, around which adoring devotees were shown with their palms pressed together or prostrate. Sometime later at Bhārhut and Amarāvatī, as well as at Sañchi, a significant thematic advance was achieved, as the patrons of the arts dared to go a step further and begin to hint at the Buddha's presence through an empty chair or throne. Other typical representations were a lotus flower, a single pillar, or a juggernaut wheel (dharma-chakra). Now, the final stage of this circumscribing urge to worship the forbidden image of the Saviour expressed itself through his hallowed footprints as impressed upon a lotus-shaped pedestal.
* * *
In 326 BCE Alexander of
Macedonia entered the region of Northwest Pakistan, known in
those times as Gāndhāra. Gāndhāra's chief city,
|
|
Buddha as Brahman
Nirvāna is the goal,
indeed, the summum bonum of all ancient Indian spiritual
systems. From the post-Vedic period to our present day, it is
important to grasp that throughout this long three-thousand-year
history, all sincere Indian seekers of the truth, whatever their
sectarian persuasions may have been, pursued one thing and one
thing alone: a consummate reality beyond human pain. What is
more, they sought this by means of yoga. Ernest Wood, an
Englishman who spent 38 years studying yoga in India, has
explained that the Sanskrit term nirvāna is not at all
confined to Buddhist scriptures or Buddhist philosophy. For it
was plainly used in pre-Buddhist India and thereby plays a part
in all Indian philosophy
|
|
The Cosmic Axis Buddhist India was a very different world a millennium after Gautama's death. A baroque revolution of vast dimension was in full cultural swing. Yogis preached a new alchemical philosophy that was based on the notion of a "cosmic body." Their philosophy also laid tremendous importance on the mystical implications of prāna as "life-force." This tantric philosophical advancement is seen to have exerted a profound influence on every aspect of Indian cultural life. The varied Buddhist schools were by no means aloof from this amazing pan-Indian revolution. In the esoteric text of Hevajra-Tantra, the Buddha, called Bhagavān, is made to extol the virtues of physical fitness. He says, "Without a perfectly healthy body, one cannot know bliss."
Furthermore, in the
compelling symbolism of Buddhist Tantra, the body of the Buddha
is identified with the cosmic universe. His spinal column,
called the merudanda, is said to be a single bone that
represents a reality beyond time and space, "a withdrawn,
autonomous zone of nondifferential Void" called śūnya.
This mystical backbone is further described as a secret cavern
within Mount Kailas. Here esoteric truth is revealed to the
yogin while absorbed in the unexcelled state of meditation.
This also explains why, according to a legend, the Buddha was
unable to turn his head, but had to turn the whole of his body
because his spinal column was fixed motionless,
|
|
The Cobra
As referred to elsewhere, the spinal
cord plays a crucial role in the techniques of yoga. Tremendous emphasis
is therefore placed on the 33 bones called vertebrae that make up the
human spinal column
Nowhere has the profundity of this
esoteric yoga been more passionately expressed than through this stunning
image the Buddha protected by the nāga. It may also be referred to
as
Kundalinī Buddha. The Khmer in particular have shown great passion in
expressing the trance-like nature of this motif with extraordinary
sculptural genius. Elegantly adorned with diadem, earrings and necklace,
the Buddha sits splendidly with his hands folded calmly in his lap in the
posture of dhyāna-yoga. Three thick coils of the n
|
The Tantric Conception
In those days, however, the conception
of "tantra" was certainly different than what it is today. In its very
early usage a 'tantric practitioner' denoted a "weaver" with the strong
connotations of making magic. Indeed, a basic facet of the tantric
conception is that of the cosmos as a boundless fabric of magical
filament. What is more, this magic may be spun within the human body,
precisely through the mystical techniques of yoga
|
Stretching the Lute Strings As tantra evolved into a historical movement, it assumed the vast proportions of a baroque revolution and achieved far-reaching and sustained effects in the cultural fields of philosophy, science, literature and art. It was during the third-century advent of tantra that an explicitly sexual idiom emerged together with an openly erotic iconography. This highly provocative meta-sensual approach has continued to arouse public interest to our day. This is currently reflected in a market driven climate of tabloid spirituality that has managed to recast the basic conception into a celebrated New Age commodity fetish apparently intent on the comprehensive tantrification of the masses. Actually tantra is very rich in meaning, but it can also be frustratingly vague and elusive, hence compelling. But truthfully, sex plays a very small role. It is just that everyone is so interested in sex! What is more, for some the mere mention of sex makes them blush because religion has taught them that sex is indecent and opposed to the spiritual life.
Tantra sees it differently. Tantra
views the action of the libido as the primal human urge. So, sex is the
ground base; sex is step one. If you miss step one you miss it all. Where
religion has wedged opposition and dichotomy, tantra seeks to cordalize
polarities. Tantra is the place where two become one. This is succinctly
espoused in the well-known
linga-yoni motif signifying universal unity. More literal themes
are, again,
|
|
Angirasa – the proto-Tantric Buddha
Now for an even more compelling
illustration of the tantrification of the Buddha sect, I turn to the
earliest Buddhist scriptures that depict the Buddha as Angirasa, the
Master of kundalinī
As discussed in detail in Guru Chod's Anuloma Viloma Pranayama (1984)[34], the important starting point of this yoga of inner-transformation is prānāyāma. Prānāyāma has its foundations in the control of prāna. At the beginning stage one attempts to control the physical manifestations of this extraordinary life-force within ones body. At the more advanced stage, the practitioner attempts to gain control over all external nature. Said the guru, "Let there be no vague idea as concerns the potential of the subject at hand. A person can acquire absolute control over the entirety of nature through the practice of yoga." T. D. Harris, last revised 23 Apr 2007 |
|
Notes
[4] Suan Mokh, literally suan, "garden" of mokh (Skt.: moksha) "release," "liberation." The monastery (wat) is in Chaiya district, Surat Thani province, southern Thailand. [5] Emile Senart, "Bouddhism et Yoga," in La Revue de l’historie des religions, vol. XLII. Paris, 1900. [6] Kanjitsu Iijima, Buddhist Yoga, Tokyo, Japan Publications, Inc.,1975: 21. [7] Ananda Guruge, The Society of the Rāmāyana, New Delhi, Abhinav Publications, 1991: 289, brackets mine . [8] Erich Frauwallner, History of Indian Philosophy, trans. from the original German by V.M. Bedekar, New Delhi, Motilal Banarsidass, 1973, 1:321. [9]Lama Anāgārika Govinda, Creative Meditation and Multi-Dimensional Consciousness, Theosophic Publishing House, 1976. [10] Nalinaksha Dutt, The Spread of Buddhism and The Buddhist Schools, Rajesh, Delhi, 1980: 10, brackets mine. [11] Having elsewhere discussed the etymology of "Hindu" and arrived to the conclusion that is simply means "Indian," my current usage is obviously rhetorical. For the very idea of "Hinduism" existing at the remotely historic period of the Buddha would be, as Gombrich rightly states, "wildly anachronistic." We should therefore not be bothered by it. See Richard F. Gombrich, How Buddhism Began (The Conditioned Genesis of the Early Teachings), London, Atlantic Highlands, N.J., Athlone Press, 1997: 15.
According to George Thompson,
Though the verbal root shrām- appears to have good
Indo-European roots [cf. Greek kremamai, kremnos;
Old German hirmen, and discussion in
It appears that Sanskrit shrāmana is an old
Indo-European word that developed in India a novel semantics to
convey a novel cultural institution, that of the monk. This is
not to say that similar notions did not precede this one.
Shrāmana as 'monk' became a much-travelled culture-word,
accompanying the Buddhist migrations. The Greeks knew the word [Samanaioi,
Sarmanoi, etc]. It shows up in Buddhist Sogdian texts,
in Khotanese, as well as in Modern Persian. It is found in
Tocharian, Chinese, and Altaic [Tungusic]. It eventually turns
up quite early in the languages of Europe... I am about to
publish [in the Journal of the American Oriental Society] a
paper on an old Indo-Iranian word *drigu, 'poor,
dependent, faithful' [a term of self-designation used by
Zoroastrians, including Zarathustra himself], from which
eventually emerged the word which in English surfaces as
'dervish.' In fact, in some Iranian languages, derivatives of *drigu
were used to gloss the term shramana. See George
Thompson,
[33] The Dhammapada, verse 387, trans. Juan Mascaro, London, Penguin Books, 1973. For more on the subject of 'psychic heat' or tapas, see N.J. Allen, "The Indo-European Prehistory of Yoga," in International Journal of Hindu Studies 2, 1. St-Hyacinthe, Quebec, World Heritage Press, 1998: 1-20. In his article, Allen approaches the subject of tapas from the standpoint of an 'Indo-European cultural comparativist.' He compares the heroic ordeals of Odysseus with ascetics from pre-historic Indian traditions. Hence when "he sleeps in his pile of leaves, the Greek hero is likened to a firebrand (dalon) carefully kept alight under a heap of ashes (5.487)." Allen then points out a series of Svetāmbara Jain scriptural stories where a king that becomes an ascetic similarly "undertakes intense austerities and is likened to 'fire confined within a heap of ashes.' If accepted, writes Allen, "the rapprochement has bearing on the history of the notion of tapas (literally 'heat')," n. 12.
[34] "
|